You are working on Staging2

SwimSwam’s Top 100 For 2024: Men’s #60-51

After the record-setting year that was 2023, we’re gearing up for another exciting year over here at SwimSwam, and part of that is releasing our fourth annual Top 100 list—check out last year’s rankings here.

Similar to 2023, we’ve taken a statistically driven approach reliant primarily upon world rankings and World Championship medals. We’ve also taken into account things such as potential, Olympic medal opportunities, injuries, and versatility. Long course is weighted more than short course, though performance potential in both formats is factored in.

We’ve also moved Russian and Belarusian swimmers way down this list because of their likely absence from the Olympics or either World Championship meet. While that doesn’t preclude them from swimming fast at domestic meets (including whatever Russia comes up with to replace the Olympics), those swims just won’t mean quite as much without the international spotlight.

We’ll be breaking down the top 100 into multiple installments, so keep an eye out as they’re released.

These lists are, by nature, subjective. If you disagree, leave your thoughts/ranks in the comments.

Braden Keith, Sophie Kaufman, Anya Pelshaw and Mark Wild contributed to this report.

Men’s Rankings:

#60: Alberto Razzetti, Italy – Razzetti is an elite three-event threat in the medleys and the 200 fly, but has yet to break through with a medal at the Olympics or LC Worlds. After his lone final appearance in Fukuoka came with a 7th-place outing in the 400 IM, he was on career-best form in late November at Italian Nationals, clocking 1:56.21 in the 200 IM and 4:09.29 in the 400 IM to rank 7th and 6th in the world, respectively. At the World Championships, it took 1:56.07 and 4:09.41 to medal, so he’s right there, but he’s got to get it done at the right time. The 24-year-old will be in the hunt for multiple podiums at the 2024 Worlds in Doha and SC Worlds at the end of the year. In Paris, he’s got an outside shot.

#59: Sun Jiajun, China – Sun will battle with Yan Zibei for China’s second spot in the 100 breast in Paris behind Qin Haiyang, and he’s got youth on his side after the now 23-year-old broke 59 seconds for the first time at Chinese Nationals in the spring (58.99). But Sun is known more for his pure speed, having emerged as the bronze medalist at the World Championships last year in the 50 breast, going as fast as 26.61 in May. He’s not racing at the 2024 World Championships, but Sun has momentum coming into the year and could easily land a medal in the 100 breast if he continues to improve—in 2022, he didn’t feature anywhere on the global rankings in the 100 breast, and in 2021, his fastest time was 59.83. He’s also got the rare ability to swim breaststroke at a high level and be competitive elsewhere, having won a silver medal in Fukuoka after swimming fly on China’s prelim medley relay.

#58: Guilherme Costa, Brazil – Costa has been consistent over the last two years, holding firm as a 3:43/7:45 distance freestyler. After winning bronze in the 400 free at the 2022 World Championships in 3:43.31, he was 3:43.58 in Fukuoka to finish 4th. In the 800, he’s made back-to-back World finals but hasn’t seriously factored into the medals. Now 26, it’s hard to see him dropping significantly more time, and as the distance events continue to get faster, he’ll be in tough to medal. However, his consistency in the 400 free keeps him in the hunt if anyone slips up in the final. He is schedule to race in Doha, but was only listed in the 200 free.

#57: Mykhailo Romanchuk, Ukraine – Romanchuk finds himself in a tough spot in the ever-evolving men’s distance scene, where the bar has been raised by the likes of Ahmed Hafnaoui, Bobby Finke and Gregorio Paltrinieri over the last two years. In 2022, Romanchuk ranked #2 in the world in the 1500 free (14:36.10) and #3 in the 800 free (7:40.05), both lifetime bests, but last year, 7:43.08 was only good for 9th and 14:40.21 ranked 6th. However, despite the emergence of Hafnaoui and Daniel Wiffen last year to go along with the elite trio of Finke, Paltrinieri and Florian Wellbrock, Romanchuk has proven he can deliver in big moments. The Ukrainian won medals in both races in Tokyo, and upset Paltrinieri on his home soil at the 2022 European Championships in the 1500 free two months after the Italian nearly broke the world record. But with all that being said, Romanchuk was only 6th in the 800 and 7th in the 1500 in Fukuoka, so he’ll need to be much better to have a shot at another podium appearance in Paris.

#56: Sven Schwarz, Germany – Schwarz isn’t necessarily in the same boat as Romanchuk, but their close to one another. Schwarz is on the come-up, having dropped best times of 7:41.77 in the 800 free and 14:43.53 in the 1500 free at the U23 European Championships after he missed Germany’s World Championship team. The presence of Florian Wellbrock and Lukas Martens gives him a tough task in qualifying for Paris, but Martens doesn’t appear to be locked in on the 1500 and in the 800, Schwarz was only two seconds back of him last year. If Schwarz continues to evolve, there’s a world where Martens just goes down to the 200/400, or at least takes the 1500 out of his schedule entirely. At the 2024 Worlds, both Martens and Schwarz will be in attendance, but only Schwarz will race the distance events.

#55: Nyls Korstanje, Netherlands – Korstanje performed when the pressure was on at the World Championships last year, recording the first two sub-51 swims in the 100 fly of his career, including a blistering 50.78 in the prelims to rank #5 in the world for the year. He went on to go 50.98 in the semis and ultimately placed 5th in 51.05, nearly six-tenths shy of what it took to make the podium. The Dutchman, who will turn 25 in February, faces a stacked, unpredictable field entering the Olympic year with the likes of Caeleb Dressel and Kristof Milak potentially re-entering the fold. However, Korstanje is trending up, and given his form, there’s a question as to what he might’ve been able to do in the 50 and free if he had raced them in Fukuoka—his PBs stand at 21.98 (2020) and 48.86 (2021), but there might be more to give there, too. He will be in attendance at the 2024 Worlds, which should serve as a good dry run for the Olympics.

#54: Ippei Watanabe, Japan – Watanabe has been more consistent over the years than he probably gets credit for, given that he only has two World Championship medals to his name despite being an elite 200 breaststroker dating back to when he broke the world record back in January 2017. That 2:06.67 showing remains his best time, but he went 2:06.73 in 2019, 2:07.08 in 2020, and then 2:07.54 in 2021. After a down year in 2022, with his fastest swim coming in at 2:09.63, he came back with a strong 2:07.55 clocking in 2023. That didn’t come at the World Championships, however, where he squeaked into the final in 8th and ultimately placed 6th in a time of 2:08.78. His fastest swim of the year would’ve landed him on the podium if done in the final, and obviously, that’s not swim math that we can use to project what he’ll do in the future. He’ll be 27 in March, and perhaps the clock is ticking on his chances at another major international medal individually. After swimming at the Rio Olympics at 19, he missed out on the Japanese team in Tokyo, so there’s surely some internal motivation driving him to get back to the Games. That seems to be on display early in 2024, having dropped a 2:07.02 at the Kosuke Kitajima Cup.

#53: Michael Andrew, USA – It certainly wasn’t a banner 2023 for Andrew, who missed the U.S. World Championship team after winning three individual and five total medals at the 2022 edition in Budapest. The 24-year-old did show that his sprint speed was still among the country’s best, winning the 50 fly and adding podium finishes in the 50 breast and 50 free at U.S. Nationals, but was left out off the Fukuoka squad due to roster limits and had poor showings in the 100 breast and 100 fly. In the 50 free, he still ranked 6th in the world for the year (21.64), and could easily win an Olympic medal this year given how close the event is outside of Cameron McEvoy. With multiple 58-mids in the 100 breast and multiple sub-51s in the 100 fly, Andrew is more than capable of being in the hunt for Olympic podiums in all three events he’s focusing on this year, but the question of consistency and delivering when it matters continues to linger. Prior to the Olympic Trials, he could do some real damage at the 2024 Worlds in Doha, where he’s slated to race all four 50s.

#52: Florent Manaudou, France – All eyes will be on the French team in the pool in Paris, and while Leon Marchand and Maxime Grousset headline the men’s team, Manaudou might be one of the most marketable athletes of the entire Games. There’s no doubt he’ll be shining in front of the camera, but he’ll also be a threat in the pool. Manaudou has only one medal at the LC World Championships in the 50 free—gold in 2015—but at the Olympics, he’s a perfect three-for-three. After storming to an upset gold at London 2012, he won consecutive silvers in Rio and Tokyo while taking an extended hiatus from the sport in between. He’s proven that he’s still at the top of his game despite turning 33 in November, ranking #3 in the world last year in the 50 free in 21.56. One month later he missed the World Championship final in 21.96, so he’s far from a lock to be in podium contention, but for someone who thrives in the spotlight, he has a chance to bring the house down in Paris. And while the 50 will surely be his primary focus, a 48.12 100 free showing last year indicates he might factor into the French 400 free relay once again.

#51: Chase Kalisz, USA – Kalisz has been a staple of men’s IM in the United States for more than a decade, and while the next generation has started to catch him in the 200, the 29-year-old—who turns 30 in March—has maintained his place as a top-two swimmer in the 400. The defending Olympic champion in the 400 IM, Kalisz won bronze at the 2022 World Championships and then took 4th last year. He was 4:08.22 at U.S. Nationals and then fell to 4:10.23 in the Fukuoka final. Outside of his training parnrter Jay Litherland, who he’s consistently been able to get the better of, the only real threat to Kalisz’s spot on the U.S. Olympic team in this event is Bobby Finke, who went 4:09.55 last year and might be hungry to add a third event to his Olympic schedule in Paris.

In This Story

68
Leave a Reply

Subscribe
Notify of

68 Comments
newest
oldest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Connor Carnazzo
9 months ago

Top 10 predictions?

Meathead
9 months ago

Michael Andrew is not making the Paris Team

Owlmando
Reply to  Meathead
9 months ago

I think thats far from certain. If nothing else, his 50 free is always something to be reckoned with.

And he has what it takes in the 100s as well.

With his consistency, is it up in the air? Sure, but I wouldn’t count him out. Dudes mad talented

Jimmyswim
9 months ago

I want us to get to the top. Marchand or Qin? McIntosh or McKeown? Let the arguing begin

Klorn8d
Reply to  Jimmyswim
9 months ago

I think Marchand and McIntosh

For the men:
Marchand: 1 almost certain gold in the 400 IM, one maybe 75 percent chance gold in the 200 fly (looks like Milak won’t be there this year) one 50/50 gold in 200 IM, then one maybe medal in the 200 breast but sounds like he won’t swim it. So best case 3 golds, 1 minor (or 4 golds you never know), at least 1 gold and 2 minor medals
Qin: one almost certain gold in the 100, one very likely in the 200, then the Chinese medley relay. So best 2 individual, 1 relay gold. At least 1 gold, 1 minor and 1 relay minor

For the women:
… Read more »

Rafael
Reply to  Klorn8d
9 months ago

You forgot qin can arguably win men and mixed medley relay

Troyy
Reply to  Klorn8d
9 months ago

Marchand isn’t beating S-Cook and Qin in the 200 breast minutes after the 200 fly final so his best case is three gold.

Both Qin and McKeown also have medal chances in the mixed medley relay (strong chance of gold for China).

Rafael
Reply to  Troyy
9 months ago

Zhang might not be rated high but she might end this games with 3 gold + 2 free relay medals and a shot on women medley

Leoyu
Reply to  Rafael
9 months ago

Yufei is seriously one of the most underrated swimmers on the women’s side. Because there exists an incredible super suit record in the 2fly, as well as the fact that she was outouched by Macneil in Tokyo, seriously affects how she’s perceived. However, I think she has a realistic chance of a fly sweep, medley relay gold and bronze, and two freestyle relay medals. I also think China’s freestyle relays are very underrated and they should be considered cofavorites for silver with the US. In Fukuoka Their 100fr relay was pretty much neck and neck with the US till the very end. Their 200fr relay was a bit slower, but not because all the swimmers were slow but rather they… Read more »

Sub13
Reply to  Leoyu
9 months ago

Her problem is that her two main individual events are super competitive. Yes, she has a good shot in both but it’s also possible she misses medals entirely in both depending on form on the day. Mixed medley I’d say China is favourite as well. China has a chance in the women’s medley but we’re beaten by a weakened Canada in Fukuoka.

I don’t see them as silver co-favourites with USA for either freestyle relay. US had a stinker of a leadoff from Walsh which probably won’t happen again and still comfortably got silver in the 100. In the 200, USA have much stronger prospects at the moment. You say China’s worst leg will be 1:55 low but their fastest… Read more »

Leoyu
Reply to  Sub13
9 months ago

I agree her two fly events are competitive, but I don’t agree with the rest. Double gold will certainly be a fight, but missing the medals entirely will be very unlikely. If you say she has a chance of missing the medals entirely, then the rest of the competitors have an even bigger chance. She’s been very consistent internationally.

And I’d have to disagree about the freestyle relays. Worlds is worlds, but all countries and esp China puts much more emphasis on the Olympics. Yang Junxuan and Li Bingjie both went 1:55 mid at a trials meet, and Yang isn’t even going to Doha. In fact, Li was faster there than the Asian games. This just shows that every swimmer… Read more »

Sub13
Reply to  Leoyu
9 months ago

100 fly was very slow last year. It’s hard to lock anyone in as a favourite. If I had to choose one it would be Zhang but the competition is super tight at the top, and Zhang’s PB is 4th fastest of swimmers who will likely swim in Paris. Hard to argue there isn’t a reasonable chance she will miss medals. Then 200 fly she was 4th fastest last year. Again, it’s POSSIBLE she wins double gold but also POSSIBLE she wins nothing individually. If we’re talking about likelihood, most likely scenario is she wins 2 medals with 0-1 of them being gold.

Yes, China winning the 200 relay in Tokyo was one of the biggest upsets of the meet.… Read more »

Leoyu
Reply to  Sub13
9 months ago

Zhang is the 3rd fastest performer of all time so what you’re saying is false and physically impossible. And although Sjostrom is the WR holder, she will likely not swim this in Paris. And even if she does, I don’t think it’s unreasonable to say that it will be very unlikely she can beat Zhang. I can only realistically see Macneil and huske beating her in this, anything otherwise would come as a surprise. She was slower in the 200 early 2023 because she had not trained for it for a while, but the fact she could go multiple 2:05s in the span of a month or two, and her stake on the top 100 performances in this event in… Read more »

Sub13
Reply to  Leoyu
9 months ago

Apologies, I thought 2022 Huske beat Zhang’s PB. She was 0.02 slower. Even so, it’s very tight at the top, with the top 5 separated by 0.24. Again, with both the 100 and 200 it’s all chance and speculation. Both have very strong fields without a clear favourite. You seem to be thinking I’m attacking Zhang which I am not. She’s fantastic. I’m just explaining why she is ranked lower than others.

I don’t understand your point about not prioritising worlds. China were much slower at Asian Games than Worlds in all 3 women’s relays. Why is that the case if you say they always prioritise Asian Games more?

China’s women’s relays in all 3 categories were much slower than… Read more »

Leoyu
Reply to  Sub13
9 months ago

Regarding Zhang, I wasn’t pushing back because I thought she should be ranked higher or lower, I simply didn’t know what to make of your comment that she has a “realistic chance” of not medaling in either event. Your point seems to be that they’re just so competitive. Would it be correct then to say that every swimmer in those two events have a realistic chance of not medaling, given the competition?

Regarding the relays, I included Asian games with the Olympics because they do prioritize it more than other competitions, but my main point is that Olympics trumps over all other competitions. China has a tendency to not care about events that don’t sort of “matter”, such as the… Read more »

Sub13
Reply to  Leoyu
9 months ago

Yes, every swimmer in the 100 fly has a realistic chance not to medal. Every swimmer in the 200 fly except Summer McIntosh has a chance to not medal.

Your second paragraph basically boils down to “China never puts in 100% effort except at Olympics”. If that’s the attitude you have then fair enough. But it makes it hard to pick them as “co-favourites” when the times don’t support it and there’s just an assumption they will be much faster.

I never said China can’t put 4 legs together at the same time, or even suggested anything in the realm of that, not sure where you got that from. I said that based on recent times, using either relay… Read more »

Leoyu
Reply to  Sub13
9 months ago

Hmm, with regards to your first comments regarding fly events I’m not sure what your reasoning is then. McIntosh came to Fukuoka with the WR in the 400Fr newly set this year, and failed to medal. Why is it that she doesn’t have a chance to not medal in the 2Fly but everyone else does? At the end of the day, this is all just personal opinion based on what we perceive of their abilities heading into the Olympics, and my opinion is that based on past consistency and being defending Olympic champion in the 2fly and world champion in the 1fly, Yufei’s chance of not medaling in both fly events is just as low as what you think of… Read more »

Katie
Reply to  Sub13
9 months ago

at Asian Games,China is dominant at 3 women’s relays;
at Worlds,China need to swim faster to try and get on the podium.

Katie
Reply to  Sub13
9 months ago

50M free. She’s got a chance at the podium

snailSpace
Reply to  Sub13
9 months ago

I’m surprised you consider China a favourite in the mixed medley relay. Last year’s American relay with a decent butterfly split would have been around gold. We can’t expect Huske to consistently split 58.19, a 55 is more likely, and the US would have won with a 56 low (her silver medal swim in the individual event adjusted to relay start would have done the job). I would say they are co-favourites at least.
Even Australia with a 57 mid McKeown and a 50.0 Temple would have won, splits that they are theoretically very much capable of, considering recent developments.

Last edited 9 months ago by snailSpace
Leoyu
Reply to  snailSpace
9 months ago

It’s hard not to consider them the favorite in the mixed medley. The strengths of their swimmers fit incredibly well for this relay, and they’re almost certain to break the WR in Paris. The first three legs of their relay are all gold contenders or favorites in their individual events. If they can pull off a 52 mid anchor, I don’t see how they could be beat.

snailSpace
Reply to  Leoyu
9 months ago

Hmm, I should have said “not clear favourites”. Aus on paper has gold medal contenders across all strokes except breaststroke. The US, depending on how they balance the genders, may have gold contenders across all strokes (with W breast and fly, although I don’t believe this is the best option for them), or 3, like China and Aus.
I think I’ve said this before: the US won this event in 2022, the Brits won at the Olympics the year before. On all available evidence this is the least predictable relay.

Leoyu
Reply to  snailSpace
9 months ago

I don’t think China is a clear favorite, or that they’d be running away with this. However, they are for sure “the favorite” and they are certainly not cofavorites with the US and Aus. First of all, Aus with recent improvements by Temple, surely ups their chances quite a bit. However, it’s not trivial that China’s strongest leg is the clear gold favorite in the 1breast, and Aus’s weakest leg is breast. Again it proves the importance of the breast leg on any medley relay. While on paper the US is theoretically strong in this event, they have never put together a time that’s even faster than China’s old WR, let alone the new Chinese team with Qin.

The… Read more »

Sub13
Reply to  Leoyu
9 months ago

I think “almost certain to break the WR” is a bit much, but they certainly have a shot if it all comes together

Xu – 51.91 (2023 SB)
Haiyang – 57.32 (2023 best split)
Yufei – 55.32 (PB split)
Qingfeng – 52.64 (2023 best split)
= 3:37.19 (WR 3:37.58)

Leoyu
Reply to  Sub13
9 months ago

Maybe not “almost certain”, but I personally think more likely than not. The splits that you list are missing Qin’s 57.25 and Yang’s 52.52 from Asian Games. Regardless, if you just take the asian games performance they’re 0.15 off the WR I believe, and Yufei split 56 which was 0.2 off her flat start. The thing is, the Olympics has much fewer events than events like Worlds or asian games. Relay prelims are also on different days from finals. None of the 4 of them should have to swim individual events on the same day before this relay. With a fresh Yufei, she could easily split 55.5 if not faster. That means they would break the WR by 0.4 seconds,… Read more »

Admin
Reply to  snailSpace
9 months ago

IDK, I don’t think it’s surprising to consider the defending World Champions by half-a-second the favorites.

The US on paper will always be around gold, but be it performance issues or selection issues, they rarely put it together at the right time. I think it’s likely that the US leadership’s narrative about this event drags on swimmers. That and the fact that the US is probably the only country in the world where choosing this relay ever includes a conversation of “morality” over who deserves spots.

China just gets to put their best relay in the water and see what happens.

snailSpace
Reply to  Braden Keith
9 months ago

Except the US has won this event a few times before despite the aformentioned setbacks. What the pattern has shown me from previous Worlds and that one Olympic final is that there is no pattern.

Sub13
Reply to  snailSpace
9 months ago

This is fair. However, Xu was 0.51 slower than his season best in that race. Haiyang was 0.38 faster than his flat season best so has room to improve. Yufei was 0.17 faster than her season best, and 0.2 slower than her split on the women’s medley, so has room to improve. Yujie was 0.51 slower than Qingfeng split earlier that week.

Murphy swam his season best in that race. Finke was 0.1 off his best split. Douglass swam her best ever split by half a second.

It’s not like China had a perfect race and USA fumbled. US essentially matched or beat their best in 3/4 legs, while China has room to improve in all 4 legs. On paper,… Read more »

snailSpace
Reply to  Sub13
9 months ago

Yeah, Huske has apparently never split 55 on any relay before, I just assumed she did because from a flat start, she has been 55 multiple times. I guess this is fair then, I haven’t really considered their individual performances in the bigger picture. Huske laying that gigantic of an egg again is still unlikely though.

Leoyu
Reply to  Klorn8d
9 months ago

Here’s where the arguing begins I guess….

I think it should definitely be Qin and McKeown. 

Qin has a solid chance for double individual gold and two relay golds, and one of his events is a 100 distance event. Marchand has a chance for 3 individual golds but will face tough competition in two of them. And he has no chance for any relay medals. I’d def give it to Qin on overall potential.

McKeown is a solid chance for two individual golds, maybe a third individual medal, and two relay medals. McIntosh has a high ceiling for individual events and maybe one relay bronze. However, other than the 400im, she’s not a heavy favorite in any of the other… Read more »

etsan
Reply to  Leoyu
9 months ago

To say Marchand has no chance for any relay medals is unfair. France was only 0.26s off the podium in men’s medley relay in Fukuoka, and that was done with a 53.21 backstroke split and 48.40 freestyle split. If Manaudou could get back to his 48 flat form from last year’s trials, and either of their two backstrokers gets back to 52 form, they definitely stand a chance.

Last edited 9 months ago by etsan
Leoyu
Reply to  etsan
9 months ago

Maybe “no chance” isn’t the preferred wording because yes there’s def a chance, but it’s a very slim one and if they do win bronze I would call that an upset. If China and US are fighting for gold, then Aus, Italy, GB, and France would be fighting for bronze. The chance is capped at 25%, but out of the four France’s chance is def the lowest. This is assuming Italy doesn’t mess up the prelims of course, they have very good back and breaststrokers and prob most likely to win. Aus have an improving matt temple which will certainly help their chances. GB could see peaty return to at least a 58 form. So I think France least likely

ooo
Reply to  etsan
9 months ago

They were also 4th in the 800 relay, so I agree that no chance is unfair. (If memory serves, Marchand said in a interview that he and his teammates were targeting the 800 relay, but maybe this took place before Grousset’s fly antics).
If Flo in in good form in Paris, I’d rather use him to anchor the medley relay without having him swim the 400 free relay where France does not have a chance of podium (Not even sure thay will be able to align a relay after Doha where at least South Korea and the UK could send them lower through the rankings)

Leoyu
Reply to  ooo
9 months ago

Again I won’t say no chance but it’s a slim one and certainly an uphill battle. Say if we assume GB gets gold and US gets silver, then France would be fighting for bronze with Aus, SK, China, and Italy. Aus was faster at worlds and definitely has the potential to beat France again. SK and China were both faster at Asian Games than France, and SK seems to be surging in this event and China other than Wang Shun has a very young team that is quickly improving. Italy was less than 0.1 seconds behind France at worlds. So yeah it’s going to be a battle

ooo
Reply to  Leoyu
9 months ago

Agree on this.

Imonar
Reply to  Jimmyswim
9 months ago

Men:

1. Leon Marchand

2. Qin Haiyang

Women:

1. Summer McIntosh

2. Kaylee McKeown

PBJSwimming
9 months ago

I’m disappointed that you didn’t rank MA 50th

Last edited 9 months ago by PBJSwimming
Admin
Reply to  PBJSwimming
9 months ago

Missed opportunity.

Andy Hardt
9 months ago

I don’t want to wade into the whole personal/political aspect of the discussion around Michael Andrew. But I’ve always found interesting how different the conversation is around 50s versus 100s. Part of this is the set-up of the sport: stroke 50s aren’t Olympic events, while 100s not only are, but they are also comprise most of the relay events.

But another aspect may be that 50 swimmers seem to train in a vastly different way from swimmers in all other events. One of the remarkable things about swimming is that even in 100s, events which at the elite level take between 45 and 65 seconds, success seems to require many years of what is essentially distance training: high volume, much… Read more »

MIKE IN DALLAS
Reply to  Andy Hardt
9 months ago

Excellent comments!

ldn
Reply to  Andy Hardt
9 months ago

K Mckeown – 50/1/2 back/ 2im/4im superstar and great at 200 free ; 4im is apoarently not that far from an 8/1500 free aptitude! what is her training secret then?

snailSpace
Reply to  ldn
9 months ago

Women are generally very different in this respect. In all strokes, the best are elite 50-200 (Sjostrom in free, Yufei in fly, Lilly King in breaststroke for example – there are more examples obviously). Regan Smith also has elite 50/100/200 back, 200/400 IM – not uncommon for women, who are generally less specialized than men. Backstroke, specifically, also differs from the other strokes in this sense: even with men, you have guys like Casas, Murphy, Kolesnikov, who are elite 50-200.. Sooo not really a good example.

Last edited 9 months ago by snailSpace
Joel
Reply to  ldn
9 months ago

She is just different.

Imonar
Reply to  ldn
9 months ago

She’s built different

Ldn
Reply to  ldn
9 months ago

Oh and I forgot her frankly spectacular 100 br which had people allocating her the br leg of the medley relay…Mckeown and McIntosh, seriously, hats off…

Andrew
9 months ago

MA doesn’t belong in the top 100. Bro isn’t even gonna make the US Olympic team.

Conversely, the sexy God manaudou should be in top 5. His alpha male energy and overall sexiness will wipe away any competition in the splash and dash 50

MIKE IN DALLAS
Reply to  Andrew
9 months ago

😒

LBSWIM
Reply to  Andrew
9 months ago

awkward….

kekclubber
Reply to  Andrew
9 months ago

the glaze is crazy

saltie
Reply to  Andrew
9 months ago

I’ve laughed out loud at a number of SwimSwam comments in the past, particularly Andrew comments, but this one might top them all in terms of amusement

Sub13
9 months ago

Peaty and Kalisz both defending Olympic champ and both outside the top 50. Interesting! Have Milak or Ohashi been listed yet?

I expect every other defending champ to be at least top 25, except Rylov for obvious reasons and maybe Jacoby if they’re not high on her form

NoFastTwitch
Reply to  Sub13
9 months ago

I’m really interested to see Milak’s ranking. Could realistically be anywhere in a 50 place tange, IMO.

Imonar
Reply to  Sub13
9 months ago

Milak and Ohashi haven’t been listed.

Owlmando
Reply to  Sub13
9 months ago

Kind of feel kalisz may even be overrated here tbh

cynthia curran
Reply to  Sub13
9 months ago

Peaty like Jacoby and Pilanto from Italy are more sprint breaststroker. Pilanto hold the world record in the 50 and usually is not as good in the 100. Peaty is a 50 and 100 breast and Jacoby is better at 100 breast than 200 breast. So, its ot just freesylers at the 50.

Troyy
Reply to  cynthia curran
9 months ago

Ruta smashed Pilato’s world record last year.

Sub13
Reply to  cynthia curran
9 months ago

I don’t understand what you wrote sorry

I miss the ISL
9 months ago

Peter Andrew about to be in yalls inbox suing yall for defamation

About James Sutherland

James Sutherland

James swam five years at Laurentian University in Sudbury, Ontario, specializing in the 200 free, back and IM. He finished up his collegiate swimming career in 2018, graduating with a bachelor's degree in economics. In 2019 he completed his graduate degree in sports journalism. Prior to going to Laurentian, James swam …

Read More »